Home Today How the controversial Nile dam may repair Sudan’s floods

How the controversial Nile dam may repair Sudan’s floods


Children playing in flood water in Omdurman, Sudan - 2020

picture copyrightGetty Photographs

picture captionThis yr the River Nile in Sudan recorded its highest stage in dwelling reminiscence

In our sequence of letters from African journalists, Zeinab Mohammed Salih seems to be at what Sudan makes of Ethiopia’s controversial Nile dam.

Unprecedented flooding in Sudan this yr led to the deaths of greater than 100 individuals and affected 875,000 others.

Total residential neighbourhoods have been destroyed whereas energy and water provides have been disrupted when the River Nile recorded its highest stage in dwelling reminiscence.

Some consultants stated that if the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam, upstream on the Blue Nile tributary, had been totally operational, the impact on Sudan would have been much less disastrous.

Ethiopia began constructing the dam in its northern highlands, from the place 85% of the Nile’s waters circulate, in 2011 and this yr the reservoir behind the dam began to fill. When it’s totally operation in a number of years’ time it would develop into Africa’s largest hydroelectric plant.

But it surely has been fraught with controversy as Egypt, which is downstream, fears the $4bn (£3bn) dam will enormously scale back its entry to water.

Negotiations, which haven’t reached a deal, are centred on how briskly to fill the dam – and Sudan has been caught within the center.

Zeinab Mohammed Salih

Z Mohammed Salih

Sudanese officers are strolling a good rope to keep away from any battle”

Zeinab Mohammed Salih
Sudanese journalist

Salman Mohamed, a Sudanese skilled on worldwide water legislation and coverage, says Egypt’s Aswan dam exhibits how flood waters could be regulated successfully on The Nile.

“We misplaced individuals, and properties of billions of kilos, however have a look at Egypt – they have not misplaced a single seedling as a result of they usually preserve the flood water of their excessive dam and we do not have one like that, so the Ethiopian dam may have saved all that,” he stated.

Sudan does have eight dams on The Nile.

“However our dams are too small,” says Dr Mohamed, who’s a fellow on the Worldwide Water Sources Affiliation.

“Egypt has managed to make use of the flood water it collected for its agricultural tasks within the desert.”

Security considerations

Throughout fraught talks over the filling of the dam and the way a lot water it ought to launch – which not too long ago restarted underneath the auspices of the African Union – Sudan has tended to aspect with Egypt.

This stance was adopted underneath the federal government of former President Omar al-Bashir – and the generals who stay a part of the transitional authorities now ruling Sudan after the 2019 coup are robust allies of Egypt.

Sudan’s negotiator underneath Bashir, Ahmed El-Mufti, had additionally raised considerations about security and safety of the dam.

He stated that if it was destroyed, it may harm your complete area, together with Sudan’s capital, Khartoum – the place the White and Blue Nile meet.

Extra on the mega dam:

  • How Trump ‘betrayed’ Ethiopia over Nile dam

  • Ethiopia’s pop stars hit out over Nile dam row
  • Egypt fumes as Ethiopia celebrates over Nile dam
  • How the Nile’s mega dam will be filled

In reality Sudanese officers are strolling a good rope to keep away from any battle.

This was not helped final week when US President Donald Trump stated – while on a joint telephone name to the Sudanese and Israeli prime ministers concerning the restoration of their nations’ relations – that Egypt may “blow up” the dam.

Asmaa Abdallah, Sudan’s transitional overseas minister till July, has all the time maintained dialogue is the one resolution.

Sudan needs to have a peaceable decision as it may see the advantages of the mega dam – not solely when it comes to regulating flood water, which is usually an issue.

‘Supply of African satisfaction’

In keeping with Dr Mohamed, it would additionally allow Sudan’s personal dams to generate extra electrical energy in addition to shopping for low-cost and clear electrical energy from Ethiopia.

He says it would additionally enable for 3 rising seasons – in the meanwhile crops are harvested round October or November – but when the circulate is regulated, farmers will have the ability to plant and irrigate extra typically.

picture copyrightAFP
picture captionThe dam will enable farmers to work extra profitably

In years of drought, when often there may be little or no water – the dam would guarantee a provide.

As it’s Sudan solely makes use of about 12 billion cubic metres or 64% of the water it’s entitled to yearly underneath the 1959 treaty signed with Egypt over sharing the assets of the Nile, says Dr Mohamed.

On condition that the UN says about 10 million individuals in Sudan are going through meals shortages this yr – partly brought on by coronavirus lockdown measures – he can solely see the long-term advantages of the mega dam venture.

Discover the Nile with 360 video

a 360-degree version of the Damming the Nile VR series from BBC News

Media playback is unsupported in your machine

Alastair Leithead and his group travelled in 2018 from the Blue Nile’s supply to the ocean – by Ethiopia and Sudan into Egypt.

Opinion on the streets in and across the capital tends to be extra in sympathy with Ethiopia.

“We assist them as a result of we share sentiments in the direction of the Ethiopian individuals,” stated Salah Hassan, a 44-year-old father of 1 whose house in Omdurman, Khartoum’s twin metropolis, was partly broken within the floods.

Mohamed Ali, a 37 yr outdated dwelling in Khartoum North, sees it as a supply of African satisfaction – and a job alternative for a lot of.

“There are tens of millions of Ethiopians residing in Sudan now, however I believe after the dam will likely be constructed they’ll return to their nation together with many Sudanese individuals to work there,” he says.

“I assist the dam 100% as any venture that advantages the African individuals will likely be nice.

“Individuals within the Horn of Africa suffered rather a lot and they should have such massive developmental tasks.”

However till the dispute is settled over how Ethiopia’s dam is regulated, it stays unsettling and worrying for these dwelling and farming alongside the world’s longest river.

Extra Letters from Africa:

Comply with us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Fb at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica

Extra on this story